Coaxial vs Component Speakers: What Are the Differences

Coaxial vs Component Speakers: What Are the Differences

Coaxial vs Component Speakers: What Are the Differences

Car speaker makers supply the market with different models of speakers, intending to cater to different listening tastes and different user preferences. As such, getting the ideal speakers for your vehicle will depend on how precisely you can determine your expectations as a listener and match them to the car speaker you’re considering.

One of the major dilemmas that many car owners face while buying car speakers is the choice between coaxial speakers and component speakers. This is a decision that requires a great background in each of these speaker models to get it right. 

So, what are the differences between coaxial and component speakers?

Coaxial Speakers

Coaxial or full-range speakers simply refer to a 2-way speaker system that is built into a single unit. These usually comprise a woofer, tweeter, and a simple crossover assembled into one piece. Coaxial speakers are a perfect upgrade on older and lower-quality speakers and are designed to fit in the same hole for faster and easier installation. 

Generally, they deliver better sound quality compared to single cone speakers and offer more price options. You can think of them as a compromise between low-quality single cone speakers and more advanced component speaker systems. 

Coaxial Speakers

Component Speakers

Component speakers are a more advanced system with separately mounted speakers. They employ an advanced crossover and are engineered to offer the highest sound quality. Component speakers are the next level of speakers above coaxial and generally offer a better sound performance. 

One good reason behind this is that they use better woofer and dome tweeter materials, as well as a superior speaker crossover. You may also find features like options for tweeter volume reduction, extra wiring configurations, and tweeter fusing to guard against overload on offer. 

COMPONENT SPEAKERS

Coaxial vs Component Speakers: What Are the Differences?

Now that you have a little background of what coaxial speakers and component speakers entail, let us look at the major differences between the two based on various parameters:

Crossover Differences

Component speakers feature more advanced crossovers compared to coaxial speakers. They employ two stages of sound filtering as opposed to the single used in coaxial. The implication is that you get more effective filtering of low frequency and mid-range sounds from the tweeter while the high-range sound is kept away from the woofer. 

On the other hand, coaxial speakers use a cheap capacitor, which is connected to the tweeter but nothing for the woofer. They use a low-quality crossover design, which relies on the assumption that most woofers stop producing high-frequency sounds naturally. 

While this may get the job done, the eventual sound quality is compromised to an extent. Overall, component speakers use an external crossover that is built for the specific speaker used and are constructed using higher-quality capacitors and inductors. 

That is why they excel at preventing undesirable sound frequencies from reaching drivers that are not suited for them. The result here is that you get better stereo clarity and lower distortion, which allows you to listen to the music just as it was meant to be heard! 

Sound Quality

Component speakers are preferred by many users for their better sound reproduction, which is a credit to the separate driver configuration. This allows them to separate different sound frequencies accurately across the spectrum. As a result, you get to enjoy a more powerful and precise bass from the woofer while the tweeter produces great high-frequencies for superior sound imaging. 

Meanwhile, coaxial speakers are not the best when it comes to stereo imaging, which can be explained by the single unit configuration. As much as they can handle all the sound frequencies in the spectrum, there is a degree of frequency interference. This is because the woofer is placed too close to the tweeter. 

Customization Capabilities

Typically, component speakers are made up of 2 tweeters, 2 woofers, and 2 crossovers. However, you may get some models with extra drivers such as subwoofers while more advanced designs of component speakers will even incorporate super-tweeters for the best sound reproduction. 

Thanks to all these drivers, you can achieve off-axis and on-axis response. For on-axis response, all you have to do is position the speakers to the face the listener to get better high-frequency sounds. For those who prefer more bass in their music, speakers are set to face away from the listener for a more off-axis sound response. 

When it comes to coaxial speakers, you don’t have much wriggle room as far as determining how your stereo looks and performs after installation. While these will fit effortlessly in many car models, all you get is a good sound upgrade and nothing more! 

2 tweeters, 2 woofers, and 2 crossovers

Ease of Installation

If you want to make the most of the benefits offered by component speakers, then you need to possess great technical skills for proper installation. Otherwise, be ready to spend a few bucks on a professional to carry out the installation for you. You may come across component speakers that enable you to mount the tweeter at the center of the woofer, which generally simplifies the installation process. 

Installing

But if you intend to mount the different drivers at different areas inside your car, then a greater deal of installation skills will be needed. This might force you to contract a professional technician and incur some extra expenses. 

The great thing about coaxial speakers is that installing them is a simple and straightforward process. Practically anybody with basic skills can mount them in a matter of minutes when all the right tools are available. There is only one input connection to deal with, as opposed to the three connections involved in component speakers. 

Price

Coaxial speakers are typically less expensive than their component counterparts. If your budget is relatively limited, two good reasons make coaxial speakers the better option for you. Firstly, these speakers are designed to save on time, space, and even costs.

Their configuration combines everything into a single unit, which greatly reduces the cost, and this also applies when it comes to the quality of materials used. Aside from spending less when buying, you also get to limit your budget during installation since you don’t require professional experience. 

On the other hand, component speakers come with a more advanced design that requires more time and better materials. This extra cost involved is passed down to the buyer, hence the higher price tag of component speakers. 

The other reason is that coaxial speakers will work just okay without amplifiers, which is not true for component speakers. If you want to get the most out of component speakers, then you need to throw an amplifier into the mix to complete the sound upgrade. 

Vehicle Fit

Generally, coaxial speakers are designed to replace the outgoing factory speakers in a car. They fit almost perfectly in the spaces left behind and this is why you see more coaxial speakers in vehicles than component speakers. 

Fitting

Due to space and installation needs, component speakers might prove to be a difficult fit in some vehicles. You have to conduct a great deal of due diligence beforehand to be sure that the component speakers you want to buy will fit your car. 

Component Vs Coaxial Speakers: Which is Better?

The shortest answer to this is that component speakers will be more suitable if you’re looking for the best sound quality, higher power handling, better woofer and tweeter technology options, as well as installation creativity. 

Meanwhile, coaxial speakers are the better option for those who simply want a sound upgrade without caring about super-crisp stereo, especially when working with a limited budget.

Conclusion

So, if you were wondering which one between coaxial and component speakers to install inside your car, we hope the article above lays bare the differences between the two and the unique pros and cons that each one of them offers. 

The market has speakers for just about anyone, but finding what best suits you comes down to finding the ideal audio reproduction for your kind of listening pleasure!


Barry Allen

About the author:

Barry Allen

I grew up to be a self-proclaimed stuck-up audiophile, and I – partially – blame Pinnacle Speakers for it.


The whole point of me starting this website was to keep the tradition going. Although the means have changed, the mission remains the same: Bringing „sterling sound“ as they once put it into home theaters and sound systems worldwide! 


3-Way vs 2-Way car speakers – Which is better?

3-Way vs 2-Way car speakers - Which is better?

3-Way vs 2-Way car speakers - Which is better?  

Whether you’re an audiophile, a musician or simply a regular bloke who enjoys jamming to good music, a high-quality sound system is something to always look forward to when shopping for a car. Some people may not understand this but sometimes it’s just therapeutic to crank up the volume as you drive alone in your vehicle.

The speaker market offers you a wide variety of sound systems that can be installed in your car. Among the many decisions you’re likely going to make is whether to buy a 2-way or a 3-way car speaker system. But before we get to that, what does it even mean?

Which will be the better option.. a 3-way or 2-way speaker?

What is a 2-way Speaker?

A two-way speaker is made up of a tweeter and a woofer. The woofer accounts for low frequency sounds such as notes produced by a drum or a bass. This implies that in a 2-way speaker, the woofer also accounts for a part of the midrange recurrence spectrum. 

Meanwhile, the smaller tweeter handles the higher sound frequencies, such as those produced by a tambourine, a cymbal or a woodwind. Additionally, there is a crossover to subtract pieces of the incoming sound signal, sending them to the appropriate driver. Generally, two-way speakers produce much better sound than single-driver speakers. 

Advantages

Two-way speakers tend to be less expensive than their three-way counterparts. This is because they require less material to produce, as well as a crossover unit that separates the signal in two areas. However, these speakers can also get pretty costly when they involve high quality materials or required designing expertise. 

Many two-way car sound speakers come with a passive crossover. This type of circuit will isolate the signal into various extents but won’t intensify it. Therefore, two-way speaker systems can offer enhanced sound quality while maintaining simplicity to save on material costs.

Two-way speakers are just ideal for coaxial speaker frameworks. These simply refer to frameworks that contain more than one speaker in the same box. The speakers then create sound on a similar axis.  

Disadvantages

Two-way speakers produce a sound that is relatively of lower quality than three-way speakers. This is because both the mid-range and bass sound proliferation have been bundled into the woofer, which is unlike in three-way systems where they get isolated. 

The woofer featured in three-way speaker frameworks handles sound frequencies ranging between 20 Hz and 2,000Hz, which is a wide range and harder to cover when using a one speaker driver. As such, 3-way frameworks sift through the low frequency and high frequency sounds to result in an increasingly better sound in the woofer. 

What is a 3-way Speaker?

A three-way speaker framework uses three drivers inside the speaker to produce sound effects. Unlike in two-way speakers, the sound signal, in this case, is separated into three different territories. The first range is the tweeter, which handles sounds with a frequency above 2,000Hz.

The second, which is the mid-range, is responsible for sound between 200Hz and 2,000Hz. The third and final range is for the woofer and this is usually responsible for sounds with a frequency below 200Hz, which is typically the base scope. The three territories are frequently referred to as low, mid, and high.  

Advantages

Generally, three-way speakers ought to produce better-quality sound than two-way speakers. This is especially true when both speaker frameworks are made using the same materials. Given that the sound signal is separated and directed to drivers that best produce the different ranges, three-way speakers maintain a larger amount of purity. 

Naturally, the design of coaxial speakers makes it difficult to distinguish between two-way and three-way speaker frameworks. However, three-way speakers tend to outshine their counterparts and this is due to the isolating drivers that keep tweeters at a higher level near our ears than the mid-range and woofer. 

The bass sound produced in three-way speakers is more pronounced and of better quality than in 2-way speakers. You can credit this to the fact that the woofer is strictly committed to the lower frequency whereas the mid-range handles the mid-range sound. Bass is an essential element of good music that adds mood and drive to the overall sound quality. 

Another benefit of separating the bass from the mid-range in a three-way framework is that it enables the speaker system to handle substantially greater power without damage, compared to a two-way framework. 

Disadvantages

Three-way speakers will typically cost more than two-way speakers, both in the segment and coaxial versions. This is because of the additional materials used in the third mid-range driver, as well as the improved crossover circuit. 

Three-way speaker frameworks also require a well-assembled crossover, unlike two-way speakers, which can function comfortably with low-grade crossovers. When you consider that the advantage of 3-way speakers over 2-way speakers is merely only better sound quality ; most music lovers who are not audiophiles may not be able to notice it. 

2-way Vs. 3-way Speakers: The Difference

The two-way speaker framework consists of two drivers; a twitter to control the high frequencies and the woofer to control the mid-range and low frequencies. On the other hand, the three-way speaker frameworks constitute three drivers. A mid-range driver has been included in this case to handle the mid-range frequency and leave the woofer to only handle the low-frequency sounds.

This results in better sound contrast compared to two-way speaker frameworks. Furthermore, there are various components that impact the quality of sound. These different variables include things like the method for crossover setting, cabinet structure, and speaker arrangement. 

2-way Vs. 3-way Speakers: The Difference

Ultimately, it’s always wise to consider both the two-way and three-way options when shopping for a speaker system to avoid second thoughts once it has been installed in your car. Hence, it is recommended to consider speaker testing in your vehicle first before you decide to buy it. This will allow you to compare the sound quality, as well as other variables, to make an informed decision.

2-way VS 3-way Speakers: Which is Better?

2-way VS 3-way Speakers: Which is Better?

Now that you know the difference between 2-way and 3-way speakers, you might have to choose between the two speaker designs. All things considered; this is not a clear-cut answer since all comes down to the preference of the buyer. However, most people will end up opting for three-way speakers; guess our brains are generally conditioned to assume that more is better, which isn’t always true!

It goes without saying that having a designated driver for the high, mid-range and low frequencies, enhances the overall sound quality. However, this may not be as simple as it sounds given that there are more aspects that ought to be considered. 

For instance, the construction material of the speaker, your general speaker arrangement, your listening condition, as well as the genre of music you’re playing will all come into play. In full-extended speaker setups, you will barely notice the difference between 2-way and 3-way frameworks, assuming that both are made using similar materials.

If you are an audiophile who cares more about sound fidelity, then three-way speakers are the better choice. But for ordinary music listeners who may not be able to notice the difference, two-way speakers will do! This will also be true for buyers who are on a budget and cannot afford the additional components in 3-way frameworks. 

You’d also like to know that you will find 4 and even 5-way speaker frameworks in the market. The thing is, adding the number of drivers doesn’t necessarily improve the quality of audio; but it will definitely raise the cost of the speaker. 

What are the Best 3-way and 2-way Car Speakers?

Our recommended choice for the best 3-way car speaker is the Rockford Fosgate 3-Way Full-Range Coaxial Speaker.


The 4-Ohm 3-way speakers feature an integrated tweeter crossover that can handle up to 130 Watts RMS. They also come with polypropylene cones, grilles, and mounting hardware.


Overall, these speakers deliver clear and clean audio with great bass.

For the best 2-way car speaker, we recommend the JVC CS-J620 300W 2-Way Coaxial Car Speakers.


These come as a pair and feature Black ABS composite grills for protection. The 4-Ohm 2-way speaker can handle sound frequencies ranging between 35 and 22,000Hz and have a sensitivity of 92dB.


These speakers are quite cheap but will sound great in your car. 

Conclusion

A speaker system is among the first things that most vehicle enthusiasts look at before they decide to buy a car. This shows the amount of importance attached to the quality of sound that the music system in a car produces and how it increases the value of the car.

When it comes to choosing between a two-way and a three-way speaker, various factors will come into play, including your budget and the level of sound quality you expect. At the end of the day, the choice will mainly be influenced by your own preferences. This article ensures that you’ll make an informed decision when considering 2-way Vs, 3-way car speakers. 


Barry Allen

About the author:

Barry Allen

I grew up to be a self-proclaimed stuck-up audiophile, and I – partially – blame Pinnacle Speakers for it.


The whole point of me starting this website was to keep the tradition going. Although the means have changed, the mission remains the same: Bringing „sterling sound“ as they once put it into home theaters and sound systems worldwide!